WavyPeter/SplashNews.com Alex Rodriguez and Kathryne Padgett
Alex Rodriguez and Kathryne Padgett are having a good time in New York!
The former New York Yankee, 46, was seen walking hand-in-hand with the fitness model as they left Machine Gun Kelly’s after party at Catch Steak following his sold-out concert at Madison Square Garden Tuesday evening.
The ESPN broadcaster wore jeans and a button down shirt while Padgett wore a strapless nude dress.
The pair were spotted kissing, dancing and drumming earlier this month at a party in Capri, Italy.
RELATED: Alex Rodriguez Poses With Daughters Natasha and Ella While Vacationing in Italy: ‘Lucky Guy’
A source close to Rodriguez, whose engagement to Jennifer Lopez ended last year, told PEOPLE that he and Padgett are “dating” right now, but the relationship is still very new.
“They’re just having fun,” the source added.
This weekend, Padgett posted a photo of her and Rodriguez aboard a yacht with friends. “Italian summer nights,” she wrote in the caption.
RELATED VIDEO: Alex Rodriguez Shares ‘Memphis Bound’ Selfie With Ex-Wife Cynthia Scurtis and Daughters
Charli D’Amelio and Landon Barker, sons of Travis Barker, were also seen holding hands as they left Tuesday’s after-party after joining MGK for a surprise performance on stage earlier in the night.
Earlier this week, a source told PEOPLE that the teenagers, both 18, were spending time together.
RELATED: Alex Rodriguez shares ‘Memphis Bound’ selfie with ex-wife Cynthia Scurtis and daughters
“They are seeing each other, and this is just the beginning,” the source said.
Romance speculation intensified after the new couple were pictured leaving Landon’s gig together earlier this month.
The rumors continued when the two shared Instagram Stories of new tattoos they received from the same Los Angeles-based artist (@ar.bel) earlier this week.
The TikTok star and punk-rocker was also reportedly spotted leaving the party for D’Amelio’s sister Dixie’s debut album. a letter for me together in Los Angeles.